But it was frustrating that she couldn't see how much risk she was putting people in. "[41] In particular, "The Genesis Apocryphon devotes considerable space to Noah." And we can't do that, because it gives us a mental get-out-of-jail free card. [18][19], Because of its brevity and textual inconsistencies, it has been suggested that this narrative is a "splinter from a more substantial tale". It will keep you up at night long after you've read the last page, questioning beliefs you once thought were true. This author is clearly very talented, and I want to read more of her work soon. Actually, sad isnt even the word. The Peacock sci-fi mystery series The Resort has ended, explaining many of its biggest questions while raising a few more here's The Resort ending explained.Created by Palm Springs screenwriter Andy Siara, the show similarly combines high-concept science fiction with 30-something angst.The Resort's main cast includes Cristin Milioti and . The biblical account of the Deluge (Genesis 6:11-9:19) features Noah as . God sent the flood to judge the world at that time of heinous, continual, worldwide sin. What happens when the child you love with all your heart and soul is branded a pedophile? According to Genesis 6:7, "The Lord said, 'I will blot out man whom I have created from the face of the ground, man and beast and creeping things and birds of the air, for I am sorry that I have made them.'" Prometheus Orientalized. There is no ark in this account. Warning: Spoilers for the ending of The Resort. God's gracious covenant with Noah was a response to a pure sacrifice. God made a covenant with each of these saints; covenants always contain promises; and "all the promises of God find their Yes in Christ" (2 Corinthians 1:20). Sending Noah back to school like everything will be fine, and then feeling shocked when people beat the shit out of him?! "No more switching clocks, more daylight hours to spend outside after school and after work, and more smiles - that is what we get with permanent daylight saving time," said Senator Ed . It was Ham who committed an offense when he viewed his father's nakedness. [36][37], The Book of Jubilees refers to Noah and says that he was taught the arts of healing by an angel so that his children could overcome "the offspring of the Watchers". In the closing scene of the film on Netflix UK, there is an unexpected turn. I struggled with writing a review on this book because of the ending. In the movie, a group, led by best friends Noah (The Other Two's Joel Kim Booster) and Howie (Saturday . Sin is just as much a problem after the flood as before. This hair raiser also promises a lot of twists and turns. Saving Noah challenges everything you think you know about teenage sexual offenders. Gilgamesh meeting the flood hero was first alluded to in the Old Babylonian Period in "The Death of Bilgamesh" and eventually was imported and standardized in the Epic of Gilgamesh probably in the Middle Babylonian Period. The attempt by the 5th-century editor to accommodate two independent and sometimes conflicting sources accounts for the confusion over such matters as how many of each animal Noah took, and how long the flood lasted. In the series finale, Sunja's world is turned upside down one day after Noawho is the son of Hansu (played by Lee Min-ho), a wealthy Korean fish broker residing in Osaka who she met in her . About Loss, Love, and Healing by Bruce D. Perry, Maia Szalavitz, Chris Oh, I have feelings about this one. [7] The narrative discusses the evil of mankind that moved God to destroy the world by way of the flood, the preparation of the ark for certain animals, Noah, and his family, and God's guarantee (the Noahic Covenant) for the continued existence of life under the promise that he would never send another flood. First, the story of the flood teaches us that the human heart in its natural condition is very wicked. Noah shamefully admits he's molested two 6-year-old girls and life for the Coates family is never the same again. Noah is the stereotypical all American teenager - athletic, popular and loved by many. Kipiniak, Hachette Audio ~ eBook PDF Kindle ePub Free, [DOWNLOAD] Prisoners In The Shed: The Harrowing True Journey From Spoilers ahead for Devil in Ohio. 817). I need someone to stop me." Genesis 9:23 says, "The fear of you and the dread of you shall be upon every beast of the earth and upon every bird of the air and upon everything that creeps on the ground and the fish of the sea; into your hand they are delivered. I think that Noah had been trying for a couple of times to let Allie remember everything permanently. The film came out on Netflix in August 2021 and takes place directly following the events of the first sequel. [14] Philo, a Hellenistic Jewish philosopher, also excused Noah by noting that one can drink in two different manners: (1) to drink wine in excess, a peculiar sin to the vicious evil man or (2) to partake of wine as the wise man, Noah being the latter. Noah's son Ham, the father of Canaan, saw his father naked and told his brothers, which led to Ham's son Canaan being cursed by Noah. Noah was a tenth generation descendant of Adam, the first human being on earth. Noah was not an exception to the rule of universal sinfulness. But it's still prevalent, because it's something that actually happens, and Adrienne knows this, and yet she's still shocked every time her son is assaulted! He reaches for help again and again, saying "I am a pedophile and I am not safe; if I have the opportunity to hurt children, I will do it. This article discusses the ending of the Hulu film Fire Island which will contain spoilers. The Genesis flood narrative is among the best-known stories of the Bible. Thankfully, explaining co. After these chilling revelations, Mio, using the mind of M, guides the party to a place called CloudKeep to save the real Queen Nia. I wasn't okay with the end resolution, regarding Adrienne and Noah's choice. The Primeval Flood Catastrophe: Origins and Early Development in Mesopotamian Traditions. And the twist at the end totally blew me away! Aronofsky arranges it so that two of Noah's sonsHam (Logan Lerman) and Japeth (Leo McHugh Carroll)are without wives, while his son Shem (Douglas Booth) is attached to Ila (Emma Watson), a . Noah Hawley: I did, and I obviously read a lot of memoirs and it's not the position of hte film to say that the journey that Lucy goes on and her break with reality is a common experience. Unsubscribe at any time. There is an epilogue to this story, and it begins with advent. So, in racialist arguments, the curse of Ham became a justification for the slavery of the black races. That is how it will be at the coming of the Son of Man. But God will never surrender his purpose to fill the earth with his glory. Quran29:14 states that Noah had been living among the people who he was sent to for 950 years when the flood started. It's a highway that leads from creation to consummation, engineered by God who directs everything from his sovereign standpoint in the future. This means that when you want an explanation for some historical event, you don't just look at the past like most historians; you also look to the future. Noah, a teenage pedophile, is more aware of his situation than his mother. Noah is also portrayed as a "tiller of the soil" and as a drinker of wine. The author handles everything with tact and sympathy, and nothing is made gratuitous or used for shock factor. We open on a snowy street with flashing police lights and sirens blaring. Andrew George, p. 101, "Early Second Millennium BC" in Old Babylonian. I'm a person. Xenoblade 3 is another fantastic game in the series, but like any good Xeno game ends in a confusing, potentially unsatisfying way. Noah's father was Lamech, but we are not told his mother's name. The Hurrians inherited the Flood story from Babylonia". The Kissing Booth 3 picks up pretty soon after the events of The Kissing Booth 2.After graduating high school, Elle and Lee (Joel Courtney) along with Noah (Jacob Elordi) and Rachel (Meganne Young), head to the Flynn's beach house to spend one last summer together before they all head off to college.But there's a heavy decision weighing on Elle's mind which, along with the Beach House Bucket . He is not so nave as to think Noah and his descendants are without sin. Before you get up tomorrow to make your little contribution to God's highway of history, he has already written in his book what you will accomplish. Share on facebook. In her office, Alison searches her phone when Richard arrives and gives her the contact information for Sabine Louseau, the Chief of Staff at Vander Meer. Noah[a] (/no./)[3] appears as the last of the pre-Flood patriarchs in the traditions of Abrahamic religions. Ad - content continues below. God's assessment of our moral condition is not improved by the flood. After the revelation that Noah had indeed written to Allie, they share a passionate kiss, before making love into the night. Like Noah, Deucalion is warned of the flood (by Zeus and Poseidon); he builds an ark and staffs it with creatures and when he completes his voyage, gives thanks and takes advice from the gods on how to repopulate the Earth. They weren't A-honor roll students who ran varsity track and went to mass every Sunday. Rather, "It is clear that Noahs venture into viticulture provides the setting for the castigation of Israels Canaanite neighbors." We won't send you spam. Among Japheth's descendants were the maritime nations (10:25). Stephanie West has written that this is perhaps due to the Greeks borrowing stories from the Near East. At the end of the flood and before God had made his covenant, "Noah built an altar to the Lord and took of every clean animal and of every clean bird, and offered burnt offerings on the altar. The mission to fill the earth is threatened by men as well as animals. Two injunctions were laid upon Noah: While the eating of animal food was permitted, abstinence from blood was strictly enjoined; and the shedding of the blood of man by man was made a crime punishable by death at the hands of man (ib. The Kissing Booth 3 ending explained. What do you do if your teenage son tells you he molested two six-year-old girls? Hulu film Fresh (2022) ending explained. I expected to feel disgusted, and I do, but I didn't expect to feel this sad. Adriennes idealistic family shatters when her teenage son admits to molesting two young girls. The final remedy is Jesus Christ. He makes murder a capital offense. At the end of The Notebook, we see Allie and Noah dead together holding each other's hands. I knew it was going to be bad when the 1st chapter ended with "I let out a breath I didn't know I was holding.". This means that when we meditate on the acts of God in the Old Testament, we should include questions like: How does this turn in the Old Testament highway lead on to the decisive New Testament events where God's Son joins the highway work crew for thirty years? He stands, as it were, already at the destination and guides the road crew so that his highway reaches Mankato instead of Janesville or Sleepy Eye. Deucalion also sends a pigeon to find out about the situation of the world and the bird returns with an olive branch. The two worlds - Xenoblade Chronicles 3 [64], According to the Jewish Encyclopedia, "The Book of Genesis contains two accounts of Noah." But I suppose someone might say, "That was the condition before the flood. Yet, "Noahs curse, is strangely aimed at Canaan rather than the disrespectful Ham. The encyclopedia mentions another similarity between the stories: Noah is the tenth patriarch and Berossus notes that "the hero of the great flood was Babylonias tenth antediluvian king." Most instances of child sexual abuse are not the result of pedophilia. Netflix. - And God said unto Noah, The end. "White Noise" opens, and we hear Prof. Murray Siskind giving a lecture on a very fascinating subject matter. Relevant (it changed the meaning behind quite a few chapters and relationships) 2. [65][66], Peter 2:5 refers to Noah as a "preacher of righteousness". Warning: Spoilers for The Kissing Booth 3. Noah is an award winning swimmer, destined for amazing things - until he confesses to the most horrendous act, tearing apart his family and making them all an outcast in their town. You can debate whether or not Cyberpunk 2077 has a "good" ending, but this conclusion is absolutely one of the few candidates worthy of that title. John Piper is founder and teacher of desiringGod.org and chancellor of Bethlehem College & Seminary. 10 Noah had three sons: Shem, Ham and Japheth. Finally, there is the threat from God himself. Two of these, the Jahwist, composed in the 10th century BC, and the Priestly source, from the late 7th century BC, make up the chapters of Genesis which concern Noah. That gave rise to repentance and faith. Today we look at God's covenant with Noah. Inviting them over to dinner to talk about it casually?! Neither does righteous mean sinless. "Oh hi, Cheryl. Therefore, the doctrine of sin stands as the first lesson of this story. St Augustine of Hippo (354430), demonstrated in The City of God that the dimensions of the Ark corresponded to the dimensions of the human body, which corresponds to the body of Christ; the equation of Ark and Church is still found in the Anglican rite of baptism, which asks God, "who of thy great mercy didst save Noah," to receive into the Church the infant about to be baptised. [5], The Genesis flood narrative is encompassed within chapters 69 in the Book of Genesis, in the Bible. Natalie Willes ~ Book PDF Kindle ePub Free. New Testament references include the gospels of Matthew and Luke, and some of the epistles (Epistle to the Hebrews, 1 Peter and 2 Peter). I have dumped friends for making prison rape jokes. . John R. Lee, Jesse Hanley, Virginia Hopkins, Christina Moore, Recorded EXCERPT: Noah being charged as a sex offender sucker punched our entire suburban community. Museum Helveticum, 51(3), 129149. Nigdy nie zapomn tej ksiki Przeczytaam j w mgnieniu oka i uwaam, e jest ona strasznie dobra. I felt a lot of emotions reading this. Her work has been optioned for film and translated into multiple languages. Ending song lyrics are about them "going back to the start" where they are going to meet with their feelings remaining the same. There is a good walkthrough for the original Windows version of the ChoS;HEAd game here, written by repgatu, edited by Fasty, with B ending information from MrMonday and RCgamer77. When others harm your child seeking retribution, how does this affect you, your family, your relationships, and you children? Also, the name of the hero differs between the traditions: "The earliest Mesopotamian flood account, written in the Sumerian language, calls the deluge hero Ziusudra. The world is more complex, and even his saintly father turned out to have a devil on his shoulder. Verse 11 shows that all this inward evil was breaking out everywhere: "Now the earth was corrupt in God's sight and the earth was filled with violence. Its definitely a hard read. Emotional one. Noah's narrative sets the prototype for many of the subsequent prophetic stories, which begin with the prophet warning his people and then the community rejecting the message and facing a punishment. It feels possible. Noah Baumbach's Netflix film, "White Noise" is a unique movie, to say the least. We spend so mu, Time to add my last read of January into my book, The magic of Christmas morning isnt quite the s, Them: Whatd you end up getting your husband, But why do I feel like hes three drinks deep an. [5] The maximum human lifespan, as depicted by the Bible, gradually diminishes thereafter, from almost 1,000 years to the 120 years of Moses. I found this book to be an incredibly thought provoking read despite the fact the author explores an issue thats considered taboo by many, and for that reason I think some may find it a difficult book to read. [20][21] A fuller account would explain what exactly Ham had done to his father, or why Noah directed a curse at Canaan for Ham's misdeed, or how Noah realised what had occurred. However, "The material seems to have little in common with Genesis 5 which reports the birth of Noah." "[73], The Druze regard Noah as the second spokesman (natiq) after Adam, who helped transmit the foundational teachings of monotheism (tawhid) intended for the larger audience. 'White Noise' Ending, Explained: What Is The Message Behind Noah Baumbach's Absurd Comedy Film? Most people in the world have no experience of lasting joy in their lives. And there is a final clue in the story about the epilogue to come. The things you do at the beginning make sense because of your goal at the end. When young Martha from World Two arrives to save Jonas from the nuclear apocalypse at the end of season 2, the two celebrate by having sex. Until he commits an unspeakable act against two young girls whom he swim coaches. It is a new beginning and a chance to have a different end. Get help and learn more about the design. The first point of the flood is that we are sinners and deserve judgment. And when he writes it down, he is not guessing. [30] You still want the best for them. Therefore, the coming of Christ was the future which guided all God's work in Old Testament times. We as a society cannot turn our backs on sexual assault, even if it happens to the worst of criminals, or we're literally saying "Rape is sometimes an acceptable thing to do to other human beings, if we decide they deserve it." S ynopsis: Noah is, obviously, Russell Crowe, a chunky eco-warrior battling to save the world - or, because the world is filled with selfish fools, just his family and a few furry and . Hence verses 56: "For your lifeblood I will surely require a reckoning; of every beast I will require it and of man; of every man's brother I will require the life of man. Rape is never, ever, ever okay. Ready Steady Cut film critic, M.N. It is Noah, not God, who plants the vineyard and utters the curse, so "God is less involved".[35]. The psalmist says, "Thy eyes beheld my unformed substance; in thy book were written everyone of them, the days that were formed for me when as yet there was none of them" (139:16). Then after these three hammer-blow statements of God's intention comes the headlines in Genesis 7:21: "Aquatic Holocaust""And all flesh died that moved upon the earth, birds, cattle, beasts, all swarming creatures that swarm upon the earth, and every man; everything on the dry land in whose nostrils was the breath of life died.". [23][18], Other commentaries mention that "uncovering someone's nakedness" could mean having sexual intercourse with that person or that person's spouse, as quoted in Leviticus 18:78[24] and 20. Rendsburg, Gary. How shall the earth ever be filled with his glory if his wrath overflows again in a flood against sin? Website Design By Jumping Jax Designs. And therefore the New Testament writers see the flood as a foreshadowing of the final judgment with fire (2 Peter 3:57), and the ark as a foreshadowing of final salvation (1 Peter 3:2021), and the days of Noah as typical of the last days before the coming of the Son of Man (Matthew 24:37ff.). I don't know! "Noah" is a bizarre movie. Chopak niczym sobie nie zasuy. Before the flood and after the flood human nature is corrupt. This is a difficult book to accurately review because the topic in question is so taboo. Its excellent for what it is, extremely well written, but it is NOT a thriller. [61], The righteousness of Noah is the subject of much discussion among rabbis. [45], The earliest written flood myth is found in the Mesopotamian Epic of Atrahasis and Epic of Gilgamesh texts. classification of mbira brainly. The place where Noah was sent seemed . [51] One of these poems mentions Gilgameshs journey to meet the flood hero, as well as a short version of the flood story, although Chen writes that his was included in texts written during the Old Babylonian Period. The way she compares Noah to other teenage sex offenders and thinks he's "better" than them? Literally, it was some of the worst writing ever. In the film's timeline, this glitch occurs shortly before the . Its more so a character study, or sort of fictional memoir. The Quran narrates that Noah received a revelation to build an Ark, after his people refused to believe in his message and hear the warning. After going on a road trip post-graduation, Elle still hasn't made her mind up about whether to go to Berkeley or Harvard - although Noah is already planning to . The next morning, Allie and Noah go rowing on a nearby lake and begin to reminisce about their summer together. In the closing shot, Noah and Allie are portrayed sleeping together. [53] Due to the fragmentary nature of these Old Babylonian versions, it is unclear whether they included an expanded account of the flood myth; although one fragment definitely includes the story of Gilgameshs journey to meet Utnapishtim. What I want to do in the four Sundays of Advent is look with you at God's covenants with Noah, Abraham, Moses, and David with a view to how they prepared the way for Christ. Genesis 5:1-32 transmits a genealogy of the Sethites down to Noah, which is taken from the priestly tradition. Heinrich and Denise play a huge role in saving the family too, and in many ways, we may feel like Wilder getting thrown into absurd situations while . Dimensions : 6 x 0.65 x 9 inches. Lifetime's latest thriller is 12 Desperate Hours. Please click the above link to view it (it is not hosted on this wiki). Now it came to pass, when men began to multiply on the face of the earth, and daughters were born to them, that the sons of God saw the daughters of men, that they were beautiful; and they took wives for themselves . It is written so realistically. Fire Island is a new film streaming on Hulu, an unapologetic rom-com with a sense of community. Essentially Old Babylonian copies tend to represent a tradition of before the flood apart from the actual King List, whereas the Ur III copy of the King List and the duplicate from the Brockmon collection indicate that the King List Proper once existed independent of mention to the flood and the tradition of before the flood. The Condition of Man's Heart Is Not Improved After the Flood. Noah (/ n o. Produced by Will Reid , Rob Szypko . Feb. 23, 2023. [77] In Bah belief, only Noah's followers were spiritually alive, preserved in the ark of his teachings, as others were spiritually dead. Later on God reveals some of the practical legal implications of this (e.g., Romans 13:16); but here the point is that a special provision is made by God to protect his mission from the threat of men. The story cries out for an epilogue. I will uphold rather than destroy the natural world processes on which you depend for life. [78][79] The Bah scripture Kitb-i-qn endorses the Islamic belief that Noah had a large number of companions, either 40 or 72, besides his family on the Ark, and that he taught for 950 (symbolic) years before the flood. Genesis describes the flood as the de-creation of the worldthe earth sinks back into the chaotic waters that God cleared away on page one of the Bible (Genesis 1:6-10). "[10], The Encyclopedia Judaica notes that Noah's drunkenness is not presented as reprehensible behavior. [38], In 10:13 of the Book of Enoch (which is part of the Orthodox Tewahedo biblical canon) and canonical for Beta Israel, Uriel was dispatched by "the Most High" to inform Noah of the approaching "deluge". But the writer builds three roadblocks to that view. Could you hold off a killer from murdering your family? Tough subject. Noah is referenced in various other books of the Bible, including the New Testament, and in associated deuterocanonical books. It's a modern blockbuster, chock full of the visual and aural and narrative tics we expect from modern blockbusters: flash-cut nightmares and hallucinations, prophecies and old wise men, predictions of apocalypse and a savior's rise, computer-generated monsters with galumphing feet and deep . like. If God's purpose was to fill the earth with the glory of his righteousness, then we must conclude one of two things: God is a failure, or God is preparing for something greater in the future. Best Sellers Rank: #22,641 in Books ( See Top 100 in Books) #660 in Psychological Fiction (Books) #1,153 in Psychological Thrillers (Books) #1,279 in Family Life Fiction (Books) Customer Reviews: Verse 13. The episode was written by Matthew Negrete and Corey Reed, and directed by Seith Mann. "Noah's Nakedness and the Curse on Canaan". In verse 7 the command is repeated: "And you be fruitful and multiply, bring forth abundantly on the earth and multiply in it.". She enjoys taking her readers on a journey through the dark recesses of the human psyche. Among Shem's descendants was Eber (10:21). In the ark, God carries Noah's family through the flood unharmed to start afresh in a world returned to innocence. One where not very many people straddle the fence, and probably an almost unanimous majority stand on one side, daring anyone to take an opposing view. It is strange that the table, which assumes that the population is distributed about the Earth, precedes the account of the Tower of Babel, which says that all the population is in one place before it is dispersed.[29]. and 3. Also, Noah's father is reported as worrying that his son was actually fathered by one of the Watchers. The Kissing Booth 3 picks up at the end of the second movie, as Elle (Joey King) finally makes the decision to join her boyfriend Noah (Jacob Elordi) at Harvard, instead of following her bestie Lee (Joel Courtney) to Berkeley. Instead, the image transitions to a flight of birds, implying that Noah and Allie did not perish. "[46] The Encyclopedia Judaica adds that there is a strong suggestion that "an intermediate agent was active. saving noah ending explainedjokes about committees Menu rare catahoula colors. Starting with the Old Babylonian Period, there were attempts to syncretize Utnapishtim with Ziusudra, even though they were previously seen as different figures. yet God does not surrender his purpose in creation to fill the earth with men and women who reflect his glory in their faith and obedience. Fade to black. Home; washington state tip laws. Job 1:1). But since this is such a rare and taboo perspective, it almost has to speak for all such cases. Noah is a highly important figure in Islam and he is seen as one of the most significant of all prophets. Scripture Discussion and Application This results in Martha becoming pregnant and giving . [43], The Noah story of the Pentateuch is quite similar to a flood story contained in the Mesopotamian Epic of Gilgamesh, composed c. 1800 BCE. As long as the world lasts, I will withhold universal judgment like this and preserve the order of creation. Show the chart at the end of the lesson to help class members visualize the size of Noah's ark in comparison to ships that may be more familiar. (I did appreciate the distinction the author made. So come to him this advent season and discover the purpose for which you were made. With his release from a juvenile therapeutic detention facility on the horizon and her husband Lucas refusing to allow Noahs, Adrienne will stop at nothing to protect her son, even to Noahs detriment. But when we classify other humans as "incomprehensible monsters," we distance ourselves from them. Possessed by a spirit in a dying cornfield, a twelve-year-old girl in Nebraska recruits the other children in her small town to go on a bloody rampage and kill all the adults and anyone else who . Sandy *TheworldcouldendwhileIwasreadingndIwouldnto, Rachel (not currently receiving notifications) Hall. However, there is a discrepancy in the ages of the heroes. Noah has several titles in Islam, based primarily on praise for him in the Quran, including "True Messenger of God" (XXVI: 107) and "Grateful Servant of God" (XVII: 3).[47][75]. Your destination influences all your decisions from the start. sfn error: no target: CITEREFCotter2003 (. [62] Others, such as the medieval commentator Rashi, held on the contrary that the building of the Ark was stretched over 120 years, deliberately in order to give sinners time to repent. I thought this book was well-written, and I'll probably read it again soon. Ad. Adrienne, Noah's mother, will go to extreme lengths to protect her son - but with more shocking, life changing revelations, how much more can she protect her son? But the Season 3 premiere revealed there's a third led by Eva (Barbara Nsse), who is the future version of Martha ( Lisa Vicari) from the mirror universe. God's flood and God's Son teach the same lesson: God hates sin and punishes unrepentant sinners with unspeakable judgment. How much clearer can he make it?! Chen concludes that the name of Ziusudra as a flood hero and the idea of the flood hinted by that name in the Old Babylonian Version of "Instructions of Shuruppak" are only developments during that Old Babylonian Period, when also the didactic text was updated with information from the burgeoning Antediluvian Tradition[48], Noah has often been compared to Deucalion, the son of Prometheus and Pronoia in Greek mythology. The book focuses on a family in crisis, fragmented through the actions of Noah who molests two little girls during swim team practice, although his crimes are alluded too, the author spares the reader the horrific details. Parenting is so funny, isnt it? You hurt when they are hurting. Turns out Moebius knew all along, waiting for our heroes to make their move before .
Heeling Powers Sylvia Net Worth, How Did Carlos Die In Descendants: The Royal Wedding, City Of Alameda Parking Enforcement, Articles S