A referee might be selected for expertise in only one area, for example to judge if a statistical analysis is appropriate, or if a particular technique that is essential to underpin the conclusion has been undertaken properly. edit the language for maximum clarity and precision for those in other disciplines. var d=new Date(); yr=d.getFullYear();document.write(yr); As opposed to an editor, a peer reviewer advises the researcher of how he would have conducted his research, and what research methods would have made a difference. The content of the press release mailing and papers described therein is embargoed until 1600 London time/1100 US Eastern Time on the day of publication, which is the time at which the research is published and become publicly available. I have also worked as a subject matter expert in the field of Biomedicine. independence from the authors and their institutions, ability to evaluate the technical aspects of the paper fully and fairly, currently or recently assessing related submissions. That's it . I was shocked and disappointed by your rejection letter, authors write, hundreds of times each year, I must ask that you reconsider your decision. Rejection is of course a fact of life for all scientists, particularly when they submit their work to highly selective journals; in less than five years since its inception, Nature Neuroscience, for example, has turned away over 6000 manuscripts, roughly 90% of all submissions. If so, how close was it? What could this mean? How did it go for you after this? Status has been "Ready for decision" for 25 days. You said the finals started tomorrow. Which type of forging is used for Flashless forging? Often, Editors reject the manuscript because the analytical approach is not sufficiently rigorous, explicit and argued, or because the results are barely significant or representative. We understand your anxiety :-) However, the decision on manuscript acceptance depends on several factors, such as availability and responsiveness of peer reviewers and the extent of revisions recommended. 2. For more information,please refer to our FAQ page. What does a quick change from 'Under consideration' to 'Decision made' back to 'Under consideration' mean for Nature? If the editor is satisfied with your work, they will choose appropriate peer reviewers to evaluate your work, taking into account several factors including expertise, experience and apparent conflicts of interest. Authors should note that as Nature is an interdisciplinary journal, referees for a paper are chosen for different reasons, for example a technical expert and a person who has a general overview of a field might both referee the same paper. editor decision started under consideration. Manuscript submitted exactly 2 months ago. To complicate matters further, editors must base their decisions on evidence that is never completely reliable. If the editor is satisfied with your work, they will choose appropriate peer reviewers to evaluate your work, taking into account several factors including expertise, experience . this is indeed the general case, also in my journal. Hi! A decision to send the paper for review can take longer, but usually within a month (in which case the editors send apologies). Obviously, the most difficult situations are those in which the reviewers arrive at nearly or . Journals vary in their attitude toward such trade-offs, for example in deciding whether to publish a paper that proposes an important new idea based on data that are less than solid. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Disconnect between goals and daily tasksIs it me, or the industry? the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in On submission, the manuscript is assigned to an editor covering the subject area, who seeks informal advice from scientific advisors and editorial colleagues, and who makes this initial decision. Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page. 9.3 weeks. round 1""nature nature metabolism. Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a2b13d3eec43de7 So, it probably means that the associate editor (AE), who handles the manuscript through the review and publication process, had a look at your manuscript and made a decision on it, most probably for rejection. The following decision types are available: Reject; Major revision; Minor revision; Accept; Decisions are communicated to the corresponding author in a formal letter, along with reviewer feedback and any other requirements from the . Register for comprehensive research tips and expert advice on English writing, journal publishing, good publication practices, trends in publishing, and a lot more. [CDATA[> Locate submission instructions for a Springer journal, Submit a manuscript with your ORCID number, Submit a Nature Portfolio manuscript for Open Access publishing, Submit multimedia files to be published online with your article. Should I write to the editor or wait for a response/change in status? LetPub Scientific Journal Selector (2018-2021), Nature Energy published in 2016, UNITED STATES. How do I write an inquiry to the editor about my manuscript's current status? I love to write and share science related Stuff Here on my Website. You can appeal to the editorial board, giving a point-by-point argument against the editors views. Since then we have received nearly 600 manuscripts and presubmission enquiries. Decision pending means that the decision is pending.They havent decided yet. Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses. youre still in the running. . However, the Editor, in the rejection letter, provided an objective explanation for this long wait. More importantly, in the rejection letter it was evident that the Editor had taken the time to read through our manuscript and had given it some thought . Yes, its appropriate. How do I get published in Nature or Science? In all cases, authors are expected to abide by the Nature Research press and embargo policies. Please avoid repeating information that is already present in the abstract and introduction. Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link. Once your manuscript passes the initial quality check, we assign it to a member of Editorial Board, who is an active researcher in your field. To obtain Papers are evaluated along multiple dimensions, including technical reliability, novelty and interest, but the final decision to accept or reject must collapse all this information into a single binary choice. I have been working in the Scientific Publishing Industry for more than 3 years now. But in June 2022, the journal was removed from SCI indexing, what can i do, so much of work in it with two revsions taking more than a year,what can be done, Why is a PhD essential to become a peer-reviewer. Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content: Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article. Editors decisions are weighted according to the expertise of the referees, and not by a voting procedure. In practice, of course, this is impossible, and editors must instead rely on a few referees representing a cross-section of informed opinion in the field. //-->